Orchestra
Background Music for Fundraising Event
for Full Orchestra - 3 Flutes, 3 Oboes, 3 Clarinets in Bb, 3 Basoons, 4 Horns in F, 3 Trumpets in C, 3 Trombones, Tuba, 3 Percussionists, Harp - Tuned a quarter-tone lower, Piano, Strings
Recording
Video
Note
Performed by Tongyeong International Music Festival Orchestra (2010)
The piece begins with testimonies of human suffering gathered from sources around the world. Collecting them was a long and difficult process, and that difficulty became part of the work. At first, members of the orchestra read the testimonies while playing their instruments. The voices accumulate until too many are heard at once for any one account to be followed. What remains is a dense, coherent sound texture - an unsettling aesthetic unity that can seem to offer redemption. Suffering becomes background music for an act of conscience-clearing, culminating in catharsis.
The musicians, however, are asked to speak and remain unheard. Their effort to hold the audience’s attention, and their failure to do so, brings another experience into the concert hall: the basic human attempt to reach another person. It also unsettles the usual promise of communication between performers and listeners.
The first section gathers this overload into a saturated orchestral climax. I am drawn to this sound, but uneasy about its power to immerse us and provide release. The historical weight these sounds carry makes their use unstable, and the section ends by cutting them off abruptly.
As I completed this part, I realized that my criticism was directed inward, too. By making art about suffering, I risk repeating the very gesture I question: using the experience of listening to relieve my conscience without truly listening or acting.
The final section offers a different form of attention. Only one testimony is read at a time, but its words are no longer intelligible; they are spoken in a language we cannot recognize. The piece shifts from an accumulation of voices to the presence of one voice, while acknowledging that attention does not grant us full understanding. The more closely we listen, the more we encounter the limits of what can be understood or communicated.
At the end, the musicians shout together: “This art is quite useless.” The sentence turns the question of art’s usefulness back on the piece itself.